North County Plan- Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the Multiple Species Conservation Program (MSCP)?
The MSCP coordinates regional conservation planning efforts for the unincorporated County. The goal of the MSCP is to ensure the long-term survival of sensitive plant and animal species and protect the natural vegetation communities found throughout San Diego County while providing for economic development of the region. The MSCP addresses the impacts that future urban growth will have on natural habitats and species and creates plans to mitigate for these impacts. Under this program, large open-space preserves are created through acquisition of land by private and public entities and through mitigation from the development process. Where appropriate, these preserves will be available to the public for hiking and other passive recreational uses. The ordinances and regulations that constitute the MSCP are intended to protect our biological resources while enabling development to occur. The County Board of Supervisors approved the MSCP County Subarea Plan for the southwestern portion of the County in October 1997. The North County Plan is under preparation for the unincorporated portions of northern San Diego County and an East County Plan for the rest of the County’s jurisdiction will follow.
- Why was the MSCP developed?
The MSCP was developed to serve two purposes: 1) to ensure conservation of native vegetation communities and associated species 2) to streamline the development process. From a conservation viewpoint, loss of native vegetation communities has resulted in many wildlife species becoming increasingly rare, and in some cases threatened with extinction. Without a plan to conserve species and their habitat, federal and state species listings are likely to continue, thereby placing constraints on future development. The MSCP balances conservation with development so that the development process is streamlined, even on lands with federal or state listed species, while still ensuring the long-term protection of these species. Currently, landowners must apply to the State and Federal wildlife agencies for permits related to endangered species. However, under the MSCP, the process is streamlined so that landowners are covered by the County’s permit and obtain “Third Party Beneficiary Status” and no longer have to apply to the State and Federal agencies for a permit.
- What areas are covered by the North County Plan?
The North County Plan is proposed to cover the northwestern portion of the unincorporated area of the County. It includes the communities of Bonsall, De Luz, Fallbrook, Harmony Grove, Lilac, Pala, Pauma Valley, Rainbow, Ramona, Rincon Springs, Twin Oaks Valley, and Valley Center. The Plan area can be viewed at: www.sdcounty.ca.gov/dplu/mscp/docs/NCMSCP/NCMSCP_pres_plan_v8.pdf
- What is a Pre-Approved Mitigation Area (PAMA)?
A PAMA is an area with high biological value in which conservation will be encouraged. This will be done by providing mitigation* ratios that favor developing outside of the PAMA and mitigating inside the PAMA. These areas may also be targets for acquisition by various entities from willing sellers when funding is available. *Mitigation - actions to help lessen the severity of a project's impact on the environment. Examples include preserving habitat by open space easement, purchasing “mitigation credits” in a mitigation bank, restoring natural areas, or by other means. Existing Federal and State regulations require reduction of impacts through mitigation for impacts.
- Will I still be able to develop my land if it is included within the PAMA
Yes, lands within the PAMA can be developed. Under the Plan, some development projects will be exempted from State and Federal Regulations, while others will need to meet certain criteria as negotiated by the County and the federal and state wildlife agencies in order to be approved. In general, building a single-family residence will not require environmental review and will therefore not be affected by the MSCP. Subdivisions of land, or other discretionary actions, will require environmental review (with some exceptions) and will need to conform to the preset guidelines and criteria in the North County Plan.
- How will being in the MSCP affect the processing of my subdivision/permit?
The time and costs involved with the County’s environmental review of your project should not be significantly affected by the MSCP. Total time and cost may actually be reduced as negotiations with the wildlife agencies will be decreased for many projects. Currently, a number of factors affect development, including critical habitat designations, rare and endangered species, and other environmental and planning issues. Your project may require revisions depending on its location within the North County Plan, timing of proposed development approval, and the biological resources present on the site. You may also be required to provide mitigation for any impacts your project might have on sensitive resources.
- Will the government condemn my land for the MSCP?
The County will only purchase lands from willing sellers. Federal and state agencies involved with land acquisition have stated similar restrictions on condemnation.
- Can I clear vegetation for fire safety within the MSCP?
Yes. County Fire Marshals require the clearing of hazardous vegetation close to houses and buildings in the unincorporated area. However, citizens raise concerns as to whether these activities would be in violation of the State and Federal Endangered Species Acts. In response to these concerns, the County Fire Chief's Association and the wildlife agencies, i.e., California Department of Fish & Wildlife and U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) in 1997. This MOU allows private landowners to comply with a Fire Marshal's Order, which is generally 100 feet of clearing around structures built prior to the MOU, without being subject to enforcement under the Endangered Species Act. Clearing in areas beyond that required by the Fire Marshal's Order may require permits issued by Federal, State, and/or County authorities. For more information, please contact the Planning and Development Services Department, Zoning Information Counter, at (858) 565-5981 or 1-888-267-8770, CDFW at (858) 467- 4201, and USFWS at (760) 431-9440.
- How will conserved habitats and species be managed?
The Framework Management Plan created for the existing MSCP in southwestern San Diego County is available on our website www.sdcounty.ca.gov/dplu/mscp/docs/SCMSCP/Framework_Mgmt_Plan.pdf This document explains how lands are being managed. Adaptive management is used on all County preserves so that management actions can change as monitoring information indicates that it should. The North County Plan will have a similar Framework Management Plan that will be circulated with the Plan during public review.
- What happens if new species are listed after this plan is approved? .
One of the goals of the County’s MSCP plans is to adequately conserve habitat to prevent future listings of species. Those on the list of covered species in the plan will not require any additional restrictions and would be covered under the County’s incidental take permit. For species not on the list, there are specific provisions in the plan that includes evaluating if the habitat required by the species is adequately covered under the plan. The County may seek to amend its agreement with the Wildlife Agencies to gain “coverage” for the newly listed species.
- Will there be opportunity for more public input before the North County Plan is adopted?
Yes. There are still many opportunities for public input on this Plan. There will be further workshops with various stakeholder groups. A Joint Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report (EIS/ EIR) will be prepared and sent out for public review and comment. After further public review, the Plan will be considered at public hearings by the Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors